Posts Tagged Samsung Galaxy Tab
The iPad2: Clearing Jobs’ RDF away
Image by masayukig via Flickr
Did you hear? To great enthusiasm, Steve Jobs returned from his latest medical leave of absence yesterday to introduce the iPad2 to the world.
While this is certainly a worthwhile device to consider in the tablet space, there are, as usual, a few misleading things to clear up. This happens literally everytime Steve Jobs takes the stage, so this may become somewhat of a series. For now, let’s see what Steve got wrong(or lied about):
1. App Availability – While it’s true that there are thousands more iPad specific apps then there are Honeycomb specific apps, Steve missed one important thing. Because Honeycomb tablets aren’t locked down like the iPad is, they function much more like normal computers do and allow a full web experience including Flash. You can transfer your files to the device at will and view websites as they were meant to be viewed.
People use apps for everything on cell phones, and maybe that makes sense.. web sites aren’t formatted for 4″ or smaller screens. But with a 10″ screen, you’re in laptop territory. You can view sites comfortably. Does it bother you that there’s no specific app on your desktop computer for Google Maps, Youtube, or Facebook? No, you just use them within your web browser, and the experience is fine.
Of course, making you believe that you need everything to be an app is good for Steve – Apple get’s 30% of everything sold through their store.
I’ll also take this chance to point out that Android phone apps scale MUCH better to tablets than iPhone apps do. Rather than magnifying the entire screen(which makes text blurry), an Android device actually draws it’s objects natively to scale. Text stays crisp and readable. Images display larger, and if the developer made them big enough, they can display perfectly in a tablet-sized resolution.
2. Price – At one point during the event, Steve compared the price of the iPad to that of the Xoom. Again, he left out some key things. You’re getting more with the Xoom. It’s being reported that the iPad2 likely only has 256mb of RAM(Apple won’t specify) whereas the Xoom has a full gigabyte. This will result in MUCH better multitasking on the Xoom. This goes back to the Android tablets being more like actual computers, whereas Apple specifically wants the iPad to not be a computer. The Xoom also has a microsd slot for expanding it’s internal memory up to 64gb as well as an HDMI output port. The iPad2 also has HDMI capabilities – if you drop another $40 for a special cable.
Assuming you include that cable in the iPad’s price to make them a more even match, you’re basically looking at $30 more for the Xoom, which will net you that extra 3/4gb of RAM and the ability to upgrade your storage down the road.
3. Galaxy Tab sales were smooth, not small. – A few months back, a Samsung employee was misquoted as saying that sales of their tablet were “small”, when she actually had said “smooth”. This has been attributed to her being a Korean, not English, native speaker, but when I listened to the clip, it was pretty clear that she said smooth anyway. In either case, Samsung promptly stepped up to make sure everyone knew she said smooth.
Apparantly Steve didn’t get the memo – he put the misquote up on screen during yesterday’s presentation and used it to slam Samsung.
Let’s not kid ourselves.. we know they didn’t sell nearly as many Tabs as Apple sold Pads, but there’s no reason to misrepresent people.
So there you have it.. Steve Jobs latest misleading , magical , mathematical errors. If you were considering an iPad2 based on yesterday’s presentation, I hope I’ve given you a clearer understanding of what’s going on. If you still want that shiny new black or white iPad 2, more power to you – it really is a nice device.
But as you might have guessed, I’ll be sticking with something Android. I like my freedom.
